Skip to content

The Dutch Prepare To Withdraw From Afghanistan

February 26, 2010
Dutch troops in Afghanistan.

Dutch military troops in Uruzgan province, Afghanistan. Creative Commons image courtesy Remko Tanis.

The Dutch are probably set to leave Afghanistan in August. They’ve had a substantial force in the country since 2006, when they assumed primary responsibility for Uruzgan Province alongside a contingent of Australians. Although Uruzgan is fairly close to the geographic centre of Afghanistan, it is very much a part of Pashtunland, and accordingly has its share of Taliban activity. In other words, the Dutch and Australians have not been having an easy ride.

The Dutch were originally supposed to withdraw in 2008, but with no NATO troops volunteering to replace them they agreed to extend their deployment until August 2010. Until last Saturday, the Dutch government was a coalition of three parties: the Christian Democrats, the Labour Party and the Christian Union. Prime Minister Jan Peter Balkenende’s Christian Democrats were in favour of extending the deployment again, but Labour refused and walked out of the coalition, precipitating the government’s collapse.

Queen Beatrix has called an election for June 9, and the biggest gains are likely to go to the anti-immigration Freedom Party led by the firebrand politician Geert Wilders. I don’t know what Wilders thinks of his country’s Afghan deployment, but Balkenende at least now considers it likely that the troops will be returning home as scheduled. Their strength is around 2000 men and women, which might not seem like a particularly big number in the light of the recent American “surge” of 30,000-odd. However, their absence will certainly be felt, and forces will presumably need to be moved from elsewhere to plug the gap.

With our own troops scheduled to be withdrawn in 2011, we Canadians are hardly in a position to criticise the Dutch for choosing to abandon the field this summer. In any case, it’s hard to see continued engagement in Afghanistan as essential to Dutch interests. If the point of deploying there was to fight “terrorists” in Uruzgan to avoid having to fight them in Amsterdam and Rotterdam, withdrawing from Afghanistan and maintaining a reasonably vigilant attitude in the Netherlands would probably be a better way of dealing with this minor problem. If the point was to pursue altruistic projects such as building infrastructure and promoting democracy, the Dutch are certainly entitled to decide how much blood and treasure they’re willing to sacrifice for the welfare of the Afghan people – even if one ignores the disquieting truth that some proportion of the Afghan people just want the foreign troops to go away in any case. And for Canada the strategic calculation is essentially the same.

It’s perhaps not surprising that involvement in Afghanistan was never too popular with Dutch voters, and indeed seems to be increasingly unpopular with Canadians. Furthermore, the Dutch have apparently been somewhat at odds with American soldiers and diplomats over strategy in Uruzgan:

At the White House, President Obama was full of praise for the Dutch prime minister for the Netherlands’ exceptional military capacities and insight into local culture and politics. But the US sources I spoke to were scornful of such efforts. The Dutch claim that they brought safety to the still perilous Baluchi Valley by talking with all kinds of local leaders simply doesn’t go down well with the US forces. “That tribal stuff is the long way round. You need to win people over with power and money.”

Personally I suspect that “tribal stuff” is likely to be strategically essential in the long term, and that shortcuts involving heavy-handed use of “power and money” will create instability more often than they will resolve it. Furthermore, the Dutch are emphatic about their willingness to use force when necessary:

Brigadier General Marc van Uhm has a blunt response for critics who say Dutch troops have avoided fighting Taliban insurgents in Afghanistan’s Uruzgan province.

“This is bullshit,” he told AFP in an exclusive interview at “Kamp Holland” in the provincial capital Tirin Kot…

The record bears van Uhm out. Some 21 Dutch soldiers have been killed over the course of their deployment, and of course many more will have been wounded. In 2007 the Dutch fought and won an intense battle for control of the town of Chora, alongside Australian troops, Afghan police and the militia of a now-deceased local warlord called Rozi Khan. Rather than criticising the imminent Dutch withdrawal, I’m inclined to be grateful for their honourable contribution.

In fact, it’s perhaps a little ironic that we Canadians, while frequently complaining that our troops’ efforts in Afghanistan are underappreciated, pay so little attention to the parallel exploits of our various allies. Over the next few weeks I’ll try to write occasional pieces on what other nations are up to in Afghanistan, as a small step towards rectifying the situation.

Advertisements
3 Comments leave one →
  1. February 27, 2010 11:41 am

    “The Torch” has consistently covered what other countries are doing in Afsan, e.g.:

    “Afstan: A different timeline from ours”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2010/02/afstan-different-timeline-from-ours.html

    “Afstan: German Parliament approves troop increase”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2010/02/afstan-german-parliament-approves-troop.html

    “Denmark: One Euro country where people support their Afghan mission”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2010/02/denmark-one-euro-country-where-people.html

    “Afstan: US to supply allies with MRAPS but not M-ATVs (see road test); more Romanians and Poles for ISAF”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2010/02/afstan-us-to-supply-allies-with-mraps.html

    “Afstan and allies: 1,000 more Italians, Turks won’t fight (pity)”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2009/12/afstan-and-allies-1000-more-italians.html

    “Afstan: More on the French (including the Legion) at the Tagab Valley/Across the border”
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2009/11/afstan-more-on-french-including-legion.html

    “Afstan: RAAF leases UAVs in cooperation with CF” [see end too]
    http://toyoufromfailinghands.blogspot.com/2009/09/afstan-raaf-leases-uavs-in-cooperation.html

    Mark
    Ottawa

  2. Juan T. permalink
    February 26, 2010 4:24 pm

    On the contrary, the Netherlands is an odd country in that there is actually substantial support for the Afstan mission, at least in principle: http://bit.ly/bBhC5K

    Also, I am a tad suspicious of that “power and money” quote. This seems to run counter to what the American generals have been proposing for a long time now. Aren’t we supposed to be suspicious of anonymous ‘sources’?

    • corsullivan permalink*
      February 27, 2010 11:03 am

      The link you provided actually goes to an article about Denmark, not the Netherlands. However, it’s still a useful reminder that public opinion regarding the mission is definitely not uniform among participating European countries. Some, like Denmark, remain reasonably enthusiastic.

      I agree that it’s a good idea to be suspicious of anonymous sources, but it’s also a good idea to be suspicious of statements that people (including, if not especially, American generals!) make for public consumption. I’m sure it’s true that the American military is trying to move away from a crude reliance on “power and money” to a more nuanced counterinsurgency strategy, but they may not have gone as far in this direction as the Dutch or, for that matter, us Canadians. I have no trouble believing that there’s still enough of a gap to create tensions.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: