Fort Chip to world: SOS

2008 September 14

By former Canada’s World blogger Alexander Nataros

Climate change, water policy and aboriginal health. Three issues that should be atop the election agenda. Three issues that start with the oil sands.

Canadians are dying. Our government is doing nothing about it. Will it take world attention to end this injustice?

That’s what some residents of Fort Chipewyan, the small northern Alberta town at the mouth of Lake Athabasca, have concluded, starting a campaign for an oil sands moratorium that they plan to take across North America and Europe, until health and water concerns are addressed.

Residents in Fort Chipewyan, Alta., say they saw this fish, seen in this Aug. 15 photo, caught from Lake Athabasca the previous week. (Courtesy of Ling Wang)

Residents in Fort Chipewyan, Alta., say they saw this fish, seen in this Aug. 15 photo, caught from Lake Athabasca the previous week. (Courtesy of Ling Wang)

Fort Chip, an aboriginal community of 1200, has received increasing attention due to the high levels of cancer in the community. Dr. John O’Connor, a fly-in doctor first raised the issue publicly in 2005, noting the unusually high levels of a rare bile duct cancer, but was soon silenced by Health Canada and reprimanded by the College of Physicians and Surgeons of Alberta for causing “undue alarm”. Only last December was he finally cleared.

Even a 2006 report by the Alberta government put the cancer rate at 29% above the provincial average, while a report commissioned by Suncor found the lifetime cancer risk due to arsenic exposure to be 450 per 100,000 people, well above accepted public health standards of 1 per 100,000. Yet policy remains unchanged.

Fort Chip’s residents have put together an excellent series of videos featuring acclaimed water scientist David Schindler and community members. Scientist Kevin Timoney has continued to show levels of arsenic, mercury and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons at carcinogenic levels. Yet Health Canada and the Alberta cancer board have so far yet to undertake a promised cancer incidence study.

Jack Layton was right to make the oil sands an election issue. Let’s hope that he and the other opposition leaders maintain the pressure, despite what Ed Stemach and the Calgary Herald may say.

While we look out at the world, pointing to human rights violations and health injustice abroad, Canada may find itself with others pointing at us. Our track record for protecting the human rights of our first peoples is shocking, whether it’s in our cities or in native communities across the north.
In Canada’s World, our actions at home shape our influence abroad.


Bookmark and Share

3 Responses leave one →
  1. 2009 February 12
    Warren Martin permalink

    It is sad to see a lack of progress between these two groups and for the sake of the native peoples, there community and way of life I believe something has to be done to address there concerns. This will take good will on Both sides.

    The Tar sands are not the only enviromental Demon in Canada!
    I have lived in Ontario ( Chemical DEATH valley) Sarnia.
    When I drove from Petrolia to Sarnia every day I would get stomache sick and could hardly breath the air.
    I have also worked in the tarsands like other people in Fort Mc Murray and it was not any worse. The sarnia plants are right in Town! Nothing was done, peopled died, there too. Where is the ourcry! Where are the enviromentalist, they had the highest rates of mongoloid births in Canada! Why do they still have thoes plants running and putting out toxins? Because they need the Jobs?
    They need the Money! It’s the price of living.

    What about the Cape Breton tragity and Death rate from the coal and steel mines? and the toxit ponds there.

    I wonder has the last writer seen the moonscape of Sudbury Ontario and the air quality due to mining there?

    Where is the Outcry!

    But Tarsands are being exploited by Enviromentalists and they are highjacking the Genuine Native concern. That is the newest bandwagon for them. Don’t be fooled they are not a balaced group of people. They should balance there agenda. Instead of them against us they should support change ( Green energy) not confrontation with industry because it is a reality and fact of Life now. We cannot go back and live on the Land when we cannot get a drink of water or heat our homes or driving our cars, Quads, snowmobiles! without electricity and producing Oil to get it.

    Maybe the Politicians can use bikes or canoes to travel and lead us by there example!

    Ridiculous in Alberta.

  2. 2008 September 16
    Interested Observer permalink

    On my last trip to Ft. McMurray, after the pleasant public presentations at the Info Centre, I rounded the corner of the road, to see the moonscape that is the oil sands operation itself.

    That wasn’t so pleasant. Nor was it pleasant to wander through one of their two, relatively small, ” fully rehabilitated” parcels of land. The ecosystem of the “rehabilitated” land was so unbalanced that the aggressive behavior of the mosquito population made black fly season in Ontario seem tame by comparison.

    Species diversity there was clearly impoverished, no matter that the area looked green. Big oil’s land environmental protection and rehabilitation efforts so far amounts to a token effort, mere optics to facilitate the big sweep under the rug.

    From this article, it’s clear that failure to preserve of downstream of the moonscape is an even more eggregious example of bad acts on the part of Big Oil. People are facing unwanted, untimely death in Fort Chipewyan, for the sake of the shareholders of the 24 different Oil Companies who are major partners in Athabasca Oil Sands projects (see list at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athabasca_Oil_Sands).

    Don’t talk jobs, because the jobs would be there, no matter. In fact, timely cleanup and environmental protection would produce more.

    Thanks for writing this article. Perhaps the efforts by the Fort Chip residents, by Dr’s O’Connar and Timoney, and by Jack Layton and others will spread the word to enough Canadians that our government will no longer lbe able to look the other way.

    It’s time for Canadians to take the reins for a while, so that Big Oil will have no choice but to get serious about leaving Alberta liveable.

  3. 2008 September 15
    reneethewriter permalink

    Thank you for bringing this story to our attention…i hope to educate myself more about this issue. R

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS